California judge dismisses lawsuit by Salvadoran journalists targeted with Pegasus spyware

Published:

A California federal judge has dismissed a lawsuit filed by Salvadoran journalists whose devices were infected with the controversial Pegasus spyware, ruling that the case lacked jurisdiction in California. The plaintiffs, all affiliated with the independent news outlet El Faro, had argued that the attacks on their devices were linked to compromised infrastructure within the state.

The lawsuit, initiated in November 2022 by the Knight First Amendment Institute on behalf of lead plaintiff Carlos Dada and his colleagues, claimed that Pegasus was deployed against them at least 226 times between June 2020 and November 2021. This case marked the first instance of legal action against NSO Group, the manufacturer of Pegasus, in a U.S. court.

Jurisdictional Challenges

In the judge’s ruling, it was determined that the plaintiffs failed to establish sufficient grounds for the case to be heard in California. This decision follows a previous dismissal in March 2024, where another judge characterized the case as “entirely foreign” and lacking standing in the U.S. legal system. The plaintiffs contended that the spyware attacks were facilitated through infrastructure located in California, which they believed warranted jurisdiction.

Implications for Press Freedom

The dismissal represents a significant setback for the plaintiffs, who sought not only damages but also a court order requiring NSO Group to delete any data collected through the spyware and disclose the identity of the client responsible for the surveillance. The Knight Institute has indicated plans to appeal the ruling, emphasizing the broader implications for press freedom and the protection of journalists against state-sponsored surveillance.

The Pegasus spyware, developed by NSO Group, has been widely criticized for its use in targeting journalists, activists, and political dissidents globally. The case highlights ongoing concerns regarding the intersection of technology, privacy, and human rights, particularly in regions where press freedom is under threat.

As the legal battle continues, the outcome may set important precedents regarding the accountability of spyware manufacturers and the jurisdictional reach of U.S. courts in cases involving international surveillance.

For further details, refer to The Record.

CHAPTER X // CYBER AWARENESS CAMPAIGN
BEYOND THE BALLROOM
[C://ME] // CHAPTER X

REQUEST THE MEDIA KIT

Tell us where to send the Beyond the Ballroom media deck. Every field is required.

We will use these details to respond to your media-kit request. Privacy Policy

Cyber Warriors Conclave Chapter X — Beyond the Ballroom

Related articles

Recent articles

Ubuntu releases USN-8952-2 to address incomplete fix for CVE-2026-103263 in Tornado

Ubuntu has released USN-8952-2 to address an incomplete fix for CVE-2026-103263 in the Tornado web framework. This update resolves issues that arose from the...

DigiCert reports data breach exposing customer information after system misconfiguration

Internet security firm DigiCert has reported a data breach involving an internal business system that was inadvertently exposed to external access. The incident, which...

Health care services company settles for $300,000 after March 2023 data breach affecting 13 million patients

In a significant development for cybersecurity in the healthcare sector, Perry Johnson Companies, a Nevada-based medical services firm, has agreed to pay $300,000 following...

Open AI models, including China’s DeepSeek, match closed models in hacking capabilities

Recent research indicates that open-weight artificial intelligence (AI) models, including China's DeepSeek, are nearing parity with closed models in their ability to execute complex...